Posts Tagged ‘GM’

free-trade-economics-cartoon

That was Charles Wilson, the president of General Motors, during a Congressional hearing in 1953. Wilson had been asked whether there was any conflict between his job and becoming Secretary of Defense. His answer has since been shortened to “As goes GM, so goes America.”

In any case, GM is a perfect example of the argument I made the other day about capitalism and international trade.

The existence of low wages for American workers is both a condition and consequence of these trade agreements. It’s a condition to the extent that, with stagnant wages and slowly growing consumption, U.S. businesses often look abroad to sell the commodities they produce. And it’s a consequence in the sense that cheap imports and corporate decisions to relocate production abroad negatively affect the wages and working conditions of American workers.

So, there’s a real problem with international trade, which workers in Michigan and elsewhere have every right to be concerned about.

But the problem is not just with trade. It’s capitalism, too. Or, to put it differently, it’s capitalist trade that’s the problem.

That’s because capitalism means that capitalists get to appropriate the surplus and do with it what they want. They get to decide when and where commodities will be produced, and therefore when and where jobs will or will not be created. If that means offshoring production or purchasing inputs from producers in other countries in order to boost profits, they’ll do so. And workers in the United States will either lose their jobs or be forced to accept lower wages and fewer benefits in order to “compete” with the production of commodities elsewhere.

4363

It’s relatively easy to find out that GM retains the largest share in the U.S. auto market and that it had some 216 thousand employees in 2014. But how many of those vehicles are made by U.S. workers? That’s much harder to determine. I did manage to discover that the United Auto Workers represented just 48,513 GM workers in 2014 or just over 22 percent of the GM worldwide labor force.* The rest of the jobs have been outsourced—mostly to the Right to Work South and to Mexico and the rest of the world.

BT-AF012_UAWGM_16U_20151026181808

Meanwhile, GM profits have been soaring but workers’ wages have been stagnant.

And that’s the case throughout the U.S. manufacturing sector. While so-called onshoring has been all the rage in recent years, workers’ wages have been flat.

these are not your father’s manufacturing jobs. Many of the companies are locating their new plants in right-to-work states where it’s less likely their workers will join a union, and the prevailing wages are far lower.

In fact, nationally, the average wages of production and non-supervisory employees in manufacturing are lower than they were in 1985, when adjusted for inflation. In September, those employees made an average $8.63 an hour, in 1982 to 1984 dollars, while they made an average of $8.80 an hour in 1985, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

As readers know, I have no nostalgia for U.S. manufacturing. On top of that, I simply don’t expect manufacturing to experience any kind of resurgence in the United States, not when lower cost conditions exist elsewhere in Mexico and the rest of the world.

But it remains the case that international trade deals and capitalist control of the surplus have combined to boost corporate profits and to undermine, via job losses and downward pressure on wages, the condition of American manufacturing workers.

In other words, what has been good for GM and other large American corporations has been good for only a tiny slice of America at the very top, and vice versa.

Final note

As if to highlight the divergence in fortunes between GM and the rest of the country, we should remember that the corporation, which remains the biggest employer in Flint, Michigan, managed to switch its engine plant from Flint’s tainted water system to a fresh supply from neighboring Flint Township. As a result, the plant was able to sidestep a crisis that befell everyone else in the city—union workers, retirees, and the rest of the population—where GM was born more than a century ago.

*That figure is very close to Kristin Dziczek, Debra Menk, and Yen Chen’s estimate of 50,700 hourly and salaried employees at GM’s 40 manufacturing facilities in the United States in 2013.

tumblr_nwc7esJNZI1udefl6o1_1280

Special mention

familyvalues karikatur für tribüne- Neue EU- Grenze

moneyoneleph_590_414

Special mention

toles04142014 147014_600

146781_600

Special mention

ntRSj.AuSt.79 toles04072014

 

This week, in A Tale of Two Depressions, we taught Don DeLillo’s extraordinarily prescient novel Cosmopolis (which was later made into a movie by David Cronenberg).

We presented it as a description of our time—of the conditions leading up to the crash of 2008 and, as it turns out, of the conditions that still obtain even now in the midst of the Second Great Depression. In the scene above from the movie, Eric Packer learns that his prostate is asymmetrical—and, toward the end of the novel, his would-be assassin, Benno, reminds Packer that “You should have listened to your prostate” (p. 199). Why? Because in attempting to predict movements in the yen, Packer forgot about

“The importance of the lopsided, the thing that’s skewed a little. You were looking for balance, beautiful balance, equal parts, equal sides. I know this. I know you. But you should have been tracking the yen in its tics and quirks. The little quirk. The misshape.” (p. 200)

What we didn’t plan on was the publication of Michael Lewis’s latest, Flash Boys: A Wall Street Revolt, which—much to the consternation of Wall Street, which Lewis didn’t anticipate—documents the profits that can be and are made through a form of insider trading based on the asymmetry of information caused by the difference in speeds of placing and fulfilling orders. As Elaine Wah explains,

Virtually all modern financial markets match orders continuously – that is, as orders arrive to the exchange. Continuous-time matching is essentially a winner-takes-all race. A high-frequency trader who receives and acts on new information faster than others can readily pick off orders sitting on exchanges – over 40 venues are competing for the same orders – before others can react. So being faster by as little as one microsecond is enough to grab all the profit.

This is how the “flash boys” win.

Apparently, high-frequency traders have been listening to their prostates.

We also spent a great deal of time in class arguing about whether Packer, in all his posthumanist will to become “cosmic dust” (p. 206), is an accurate representation of our contemporary subjectivity. The general opinion was that, no, Packer lives in a virtual world devoid of “real” human contact and is too callous and lacking in empathy to tell us anything about ourselves. My own view, for what it’s worth, is that today—more than a century after Nietzsche and when we communicate with and learn about others (and, of course, ourselves) in the on-line world of  Facebook and other social media—Packer does tell us a great deal about what we have become or, at least, are on our way to becoming.

Of course, I could have also made the argument that we have become a nation that cuts food stamps and extended unemployment benefits for our fellow citizens. And of not changing faulty ignition switches directly linked to the deaths of at least 13 people because it would have added about a dollar to the cost of each car.

toles04042014

Special mention

146631_600 146671_600

poverty-and-marriage-650

Special mention

0326toon_wasserman-1947.r 140326_Hobby_Lobby_t618